Shelter Island Vacation Rentals in New York
Our Shelter Island vacation rentals section includes the cottage and home rentals listed below.
Please click on the description to view more information about any of the vacation rentals in Shelter Island, New York.
Our inventory of Shelter Island home rentals changes frequently, so please bookmark this page and check back often. You may also be interested in East Marion (5 miles), Southold (5 miles), Sag Harbor (6 miles), Orient Point (8 miles), and Bridgehampton (9 miles) for additional vacation rental options.
| Results 1 - 8 of 8 |
Description
Type
Beds
Baths
Sleeps
Avg. Rate
Charming historic home with ocean
This special house is located on a bluff with a private view overlooking the ocean and a wrap around porch. Recently renovated...
This special house is located on a bluff with a private view overlooking the ocean and a wrap around porch. Recently renovated...
Home
5
2
8
$1,000/wk
$14,595/mth
$14,595/mth
>>> Romantic Beach Getaway! Seclusion,
A Very Romantic Getaway Vacation Cottage Home Rental in the Estate Section of Shelter Island (built 2002). Available Seasona...
A Very Romantic Getaway Vacation Cottage Home Rental in the Estate Section of Shelter Island (built 2002). Available Seasona...
Cottage
2
1.5
4
$349/nt
$2,876/wk
$9,612/mth
$2,876/wk
$9,612/mth
4 Bedroom with luscious private
Enjoy this 4 Bedroom, 3 bath, with a 20 x 40 heated pool on privately landscaped tranquil acre within a short stroll to...
Enjoy this 4 Bedroom, 3 bath, with a 20 x 40 heated pool on privately landscaped tranquil acre within a short stroll to...
Home
4
3
10
$2,026/wk
$6,710/mth
$6,710/mth
Shelter Island Summer Rental
4 BR, 2 bath sunny, private home with south exposure and heated gunite pool surrounded by mahogany decks. Large open...
4 BR, 2 bath sunny, private home with south exposure and heated gunite pool surrounded by mahogany decks. Large open...
Home
4
2
8
$320/nt
$1,600/wk
$3,200/mth
$1,600/wk
$3,200/mth
- >>>hamptons - Shelter Island Ny -
Located across street from waterfront, Our new Beach Vacation Home Rental is on the exclusive Shelter Island, "The Jewel...
Located across street from waterfront, Our new Beach Vacation Home Rental is on the exclusive Shelter Island, "The Jewel...
Home
3
3
8
$371/nt
$6,004/wk
$11,158/mth
$6,004/wk
$11,158/mth
Shelter Island, Contemporary
Contemporary, light filled 3 bedroom, 3 bath home located near South Ferry with easy access to the Hamptons. The lovely...
Contemporary, light filled 3 bedroom, 3 bath home located near South Ferry with easy access to the Hamptons. The lovely...
Home
3
3
6
$2,905/wk
$9,500/mth
$9,500/mth
Fabulous Beach Getaway
Looking for a great summer retreat? Restaurants, antiquing, wineries, biking, canoeing, tennis, golf and of course...
Looking for a great summer retreat? Restaurants, antiquing, wineries, biking, canoeing, tennis, golf and of course...
Home
3
2
6
