Located on edge of town, but with the feel of the forest!
Located on edge of town, but with the feel of the forest!
2 Reviews

From $135 / night

12445 Old Hill City Road, Hill City, SD 57745
Tin Mill Cottage
2 bedrooms
6 guests
Varies min stay

Overview Description


Bedrooms: 2
Bathrooms: 1
Sleeps: 6
Type: Cabin
Per night: $135 - $245
Pets allowed: No
Internet: Yes
Description of the Hill City vacation cabin rental
Newly remodeled 2 bedroom cottage on a hillside over-looking Hill City. Wooded, Quiet lot. Each bedroom has a queen bed and there is a full-size innerspring mattress futon in the living room. One bathroom with tub and shower. Spacious kitchen with new cabinets and dishwasher. Living room with electric fireplace.
1260 sq.ft., laundry, wall AC units, TV, gas grill, and hot tub on the deck.
If this cabin is not available (see the calendar) ask us about other rentals. We have several rentals in the Hill City area.
Area Information
Forested back yard. Within walking distance down the hillside to Main Street Hill City. Easy access to the Mickelson Hiking and Bike Trail.

About the owner

Owner Profile

Marcia M Benning

Marcia M Benning

Marcia M Benning


Availability Calendar



Begins Ends Week
Weekly Monthly Min
Sep 06 2016 May 25 2017 $135 $135 - - 2 Nights
May 26 2017 Jul 29 2017 $185 $185 - - 3 Nights
Jul 30 2017 Aug 03 2018 $200 $200 - - 3 Nights
Aug 04 2017 Aug 13 2017 $245 $245 - - 6 Nights
Aug 14 2017 Sep 04 2017 $185 $185 - - 3 Nights
Aug 15 2017 Sep 05 2017 $175 $175 - - 3 Nights
Sep 05 2017 May 24 2018 $135 $135 - - 2 Nights
View all periods
Check In: 3 p.m. Check Out: 10 a.m.
Lodging tax: 9%
Deposits: Deposits depend on the number of nights reserved. Deposits of two nights for a reservation less than 7 nights are usually requested to guarantee first and last night's stay. Additional deposits needed for reservations exceeding 7 nights. We require a 3 month notice of cancellation for refund of deposits minus a $50 cancellation fee. We will make exceptions for severe weather that prohibits travel.
Payment Options: Discover, Mastercard, Money Order, Personal Check, Visa
Other Fees: One time cleaning fee of $65.00 for each reservation in this cabin. You will be asked to sign a hot tub use agreement and provide a credit card # for a damage deposit for the hot tub. Open Year around.



  • Beds

  • 2 Queen Beds
  • 1 Sofa Bed
  • Features

  • Air Conditioning
  • Full Kitchen
  • Hot Tub
  • Patio
  • Deck
  • Heating
  • Linens Provided
  • View (Mountains)
  • Fireplace
  • High Speed Internet
  • Parking Included
  • Appliances

  • CD Player
  • Gas Grill
  • Oven
  • TV (Cable/Satellite)
  • Ceiling Fan
  • Hair Dryer
  • Radio
  • Telephone
  • Coffee Maker
  • Ice Maker
  • Refrigerator (Full)
  • Toaster
  • DVD Player
  • Iron
  • Stove
  • Washer/Dryer
  • Dishwasher
  • Microwave
  • Activities

  • Bicycling
    (<1 mile)
  • Lake
    (<1 mile)
  • Shopping Area
    (<1 mile)
  • Miniature Golf
    (4 miles)
  • Fishing
    (<1 mile)
  • Park
    (<1 mile)
  • Ice Skating
    (1 mile)
  • Boating
    (6 miles)
  • Grocery Store
    (<1 mile)
  • Playground
    (<1 mile)
  • Hunting
    (2 miles)
  • Jet Skiing
    (6 miles)
  • Hiking
    (<1 mile)
  • Restaurant
    (<1 mile)
  • Winery
    (3 miles)
  • Movie Theater
    (25 miles)
See all

Reviews (2)

Reviews for this vacation cabin rental in Hill City, South Dakota

Have you been a guest of this property? Write a review!
2 reviews
Jim Hawkins

Tin Mill Cottage

Jim Hawkins

Gillette, Wyoming

Tin Mill Cottage

September 25, 2016

Really enjoyed our stay at Tin Mill Cottage. We especially enjoyed the hot tub at the end of each day riding motorcycles through the Black Hills. Great place to stay, will come back again.

Marcia M Benning

Owner's reply:

Thank you for taking the time to share your experience here in Hill City and at the Tin Mill Cottage. September in a beautiful month to visit the Hills. We love having repeat guests and will look forward to your next stay.
Sincerely, Marcia

Donald Mitchell

Quiet Getaway

Donald Mitchell

Corsica, SD

Quiet Getaway

April 4, 2016

As a family (husband, wife, two teenage boys), we were looking for a quiet place to decompress during Spring Break. The Tin Mill Cottage certainly fit the bill for us. It had all of the comforts of home and was easily accessible to a grocery store. The staff answered all of our questions as needed, but gave us our privacy. We were pleased with the experience and would gladly return as opportunity permits.

Marcia M Benning

Owner's reply:

Thank you so much for taking the time to write this review and sharing your compliments with us and with future guests. The Tin Mill Cottage is a modest accommodation centrally located in the Black Hills. It comes with updated modern conveniences like Wi-fi and cable TV, fully furnished kitchen with dishwasher............yet the feel of the woods like you "really are camping out!"
We hope you can return again another time.
Marcia Benning, Residential Rental Agent

Owner Supplied Testimonials

Scott G said...

Jan 13, 2012

Great spot on a hill above town

12445 Old Hill City Road, Hill City, SD, 57745, United States (255481)

Date of Stay January 3, 2012

We recently stayed here for 4 nights and it was fantastic! We loved the fireplace, hot tub and deck. It was the perfect spot for staying in the Black Hills and the cabin (house really!) gave us the convienience of staying at home to cook most of the time, but there are also great places to eat close by. The grocery store was just down the hill and they had a good selection of food. The internet allowed me to catch up on some work things and the staff was awsome to work with when we had trouble with the service. It was quiet, comfortable and warm. One night while grilling, a doe and her two yearling fawns came down the hill to visit us! We thoroughly enjoyed our stay!

Sara T said...

Jul 1, 2013

Can't wait to go back

12445 Old Hill City Road, Hill City, SD, 57745, United States (255481)
Date of Stay June 24, 2013

We had such a wonderful stay in the Black Hills and a big part of that was this cabin we rented. The place was VERY clean, well laid out, nicely stocked with everything we could need and conveniently located for all of our site seeing - the pictures don't do it justice! It was great to be able to eat most meals at "home" instead of having to eat out all the time and the hot tub was a wonderful way to relax at the end of the day! It was fun seeing deer/turkeys in the yard. They really thought of everything from the directions on how to get to the office to check-in, the supplies in the cabin including fans and extra pillows to some information on the attractions/things to do. Every part of our stay with them was hassle free! We can't wait to come back and are eager to rent this place again.

Have you been a guest of this property?
Write a review!

Interested in Renting this Property?

Page Views This month: 13 This year: 522 Since listed: 1,618
Last updated: October 4, 2016

Contact Owner

$135 / night
Getting your price...


Be sure to share:

  • Some info about you
  • Who is coming with you?
  • What brings you to Hill City?
  • What about this home interests you?

Owner Profile

Marcia M Benning

Marcia M Benning

1800-493 --7977

More about the owner

Other properties from owner