Lakefront Lodge

Lodge facing lake.  lst = gameroom, 2nd = porch & living area, 3rd = bedrooms
Lodge facing lake.  lst = gameroom, 2nd = porch & living area, 3rd = bedroomsscreened porch overlooking lakePrivate dock overlooking nature preserveWooded groundsEarly morning hazy view40' screened porch overlooking lake, w/bed at far end -- great sleeping porch!Two seating areas in living room, plus harvest dining table with seating for 8Seating area in living roomSeating area in living roomQueen bedroomQueen bedroomBedroom suiteQueen bedroomGreen Bedroom SuiteTwo updated country bathrooms with showers (no tub)Any closer to the water and you'd be swimming!

From $400 / night

2278 Highway 28, Oneonta, NY 13820
Lakefront Lodge
6 bedrooms
11 guests
Varies min stay

Overview Description


Bedrooms: 6
Bathrooms: 3
Sleeps: 11
Type: Home
Per night: $400 - $475
Per week: $2,800 - $3,250
Pets allowed: No
Internet: Yes
Description of the Oneonta vacation home rental
Known as the "Grande Dame of Goodyear Lake" this authentic Adirondacks lodge was built in 1901 right on the edge of the lake. A gambling retreat in her early years, a speakeasy during the depression, an Olympics kayak training facility in the '70s, now our future retirement home. Totally updated, original hardwood floors throughout, 2 fireplaces, farmhouse dining table, 40' screened sleeping porch overlooking the lake, gameroom. Each bedroom has its own flat-screen TV for a total of 8 including a 42" in living room. WIFI, DVD, air-conditioned bedrooms, etc.

Upstairs there are three 2-bedroom suites. Each consists of a separate queen bedroom, and single bedroom. Each suite overlooks the lake. There is a bathroom on each floor

Home is totally furnished and includes all bed/bath linens.

Uniquely situated on 2 acres of woods and 600' of lakefront property (ski lake), 6 miles to Oneonta (SUNY Oneonta and Hartwick colleges), and 12 miles to Cooperstown (Baseball Hall of Fame). Perfect for homecoming, parents weekend and graduation events.

Gorgeous sunrises across the lake, directly across from State nature preserve, and next to Colliers Dam.

Paddle boats and canoes provided, boating, fishing, swmming, private dock.

On the same property but separated by woods and a gate is Amy's Boathouse. This is a 2 BR/1 BA apt. literally located out over the water. This house can be rented separately for $1675/week and it sleeps 7 max with a king bed, 2 queens and a rollaway.

amy maynard

Area Information
Lake community providing seclusion and privacy, yet close to it all. Typical fast food restaurants and big-box store shopping in both Oneonta and Cooperstown. Tons of antique shops and local restaurants as well. Some of the best fine dining in upstate NY.

About the owner

Owner Profile

amy maynard

amy maynard

amy maynard



Begins Ends Week
Weekly Monthly Min
Nov 23 2015 Dec 04 2017 $475 $475 $3,250 - 5 Nights
Sep 08 2016 May 31 2017 $400 $400 $2,800 - 3 Nights
Check In: 4 p.m. Check Out: 9 a.m.
Lodging tax: 4%
Deposits: $300 refundable security deposit.
Payment Options: Cashier's Check, Money Order, PayPal, Personal Check
Other Fees: $150 cleaning fee.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: How close are you to Cooperstown and Baseball Hall of Fame?
A: In the summer months, we cater to the baseball crowd. We are one of the first properties that is totally rented for every season (because of our reputation!). We are conveniently located just south of Cooperstown, directly on Goodyear Lake.
Q: What makes your vacation rental special?
A: Property is authentic Adirondack Lodge, built in 1901 and lovingly maintained ever since. Plus, there's space for everyone, and the lake provides enjoyment and fun for everyone.
Q: How close are you to Oneonta and the local colleges?
A: 6 miles/10 minutes outside of Village limits.
Page Views This month: 1 This year: 4 Since listed: 2,213