Shelter Island Paradise

Front of house
Front of housePool and deckKitchen viewGreat RoomView to creekHouse frontFront of house and sideExternal entrance to basementDining RoomBedroom 2Bedroom 3Bedroom 4
1 Review

From $400 / night

11 Wheeler Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Shelter Island Paradise
4 bedrooms
8 guests
7 night min

Overview Description


Bedrooms: 4
Bathrooms: 4
Sleeps: 8
Type: Home
Per week: $3,000 - $5,900
Per month: $12,000 - $24,000
Pets allowed: No
Internet: Yes
Description of the Shelter Island vacation home rental
Newly renovated spectacular cedar shingle house on silver beach lagoon. Luxuriously finished with beautiful European bespoke kitchen. Kitchen fully fitted with 6 burner pro range and separate large utility room. Extremely large kitchen with eat in table for 8 people. Very private and direct water access.

Airy and full of light great room with soaring ceilings and minstrel gallery looking out onto deck with pool. Situated on one and a half acres of landscaped gardens with double entrance.

Four bedrooms including two master suites. Three on the ground floor including one master suite. Sumptuously finished with large tiled showers and tub. Upstairs one extremely large master suite with travartine tiled master bathroom. Beautiful shower and stand alone tub. This bedroom has a balcony with views of the garden and creek. Multi zoned air conditioning.

Wrap around porch overlooking front garden. Relax on enormous mahogany deck area with 18x30 pool. Pool overlooks tranquil back garden which runs down to the creek with direct water access. The house is located near a town boat launch, is a short walk to Shell Beach and many private beaches for the Silver Beach community. A bicycle ride to Crescent and Sunset Beach.

nicky hunt

Area Information
Shelter Island is situated between the North and South Fork accessed by a short ferry ride from Sag Harbour [5 mins] or Greenport [10 mins]. It is an unspoilt tranquil oasis. It is an 8,000 acre paradise with many small beaches, fresh water pond, hiking, walking and the attraction of the Mashomack Nature Reserve. Evening concerts at the renowned Perlman music school finish off an idyllic day. Many small restaurants with wonderful food. Sailing school, kayak rentals etc

Nearby Greenport provides small town athmosphere with restaurants and cinema as does the old whaling village of Sag Harbour on the South Fork. All the facilities of the Hamptons are on your doorstep.

Easily accessible by bus or train from Manhattan.

About the owner

Owner Profile



Begins Ends Week
Weekly Monthly Min
May 01 2017 May 31 2017 - - $4,000 $15,000 1 Week
Jun 01 2017 Jun 30 2017 - - $4,500 $18,000 1 Week
Jul 01 2017 Jul 31 2017 - - $4,900 $20,000 1 Week
Aug 01 2017 Aug 31 2017 - - $5,900 $24,000 1 Week
Sep 01 2017 Sep 30 2017 - - $4,000 $15,000 1 Week
Sep 01 2017 Sep 30 2017 - - $4,500 $18,000 1 Week
Oct 01 2017 Oct 30 2017 - - $3,000 $12,000 1 Week
View all periods
Check In: 3 p.m. Check Out: 10 a.m.
Deposits: 50% of the rental rate is required when making a reservation A separate security deposit of $2,000 is required until inventory and property is checked at rental completion. Damage or loss to be deducted from deposit. Applicable refund to be made within 2 weeks of end of rental period.
Payment Options: Cashier's Check, PayPal, Visa
Other Fees: There will be a separate utility charge for electricity,gas usage. A final cleaning charge of $200 will be levied.

Reviews (1)

Reviews for this vacation home rental in Shelter Island, New York

Have you been a guest of this property? Write a review!
1 review

Truly a Shelter Island Paradise for sure!!


Toledo, Ohio USA

Truly a Shelter Island Paradise for sure!!

August 2, 2010

We spent an enjoyable time at this beautiful Shelter Island Home. The owners of the home were terrific to interact with & the whole rental process was seamless. The home is much prettier & larger than even described. The bedding, linens, kitchen implements all top of the line. The home was immaculate when we entered for the 1st time. There are tons of activites right near the house which are included kayaks, ping pong, fooz-ball, swimming at beach or in the pool. We went to the South Shore for Hampton Beaches & Montauk Light House. We hit Greenport for dinner & movies..We did use the central air, but mostly we could enjoy the lovely breezes thru the french doors & bright open windows. You won't go wrong renting this property. Shelter Island is a marvelous place to vacation w/family, friends, children...Truly a relaxing and re-newing vacation.

Owner Supplied Testimonials

The house was recently fully renovated and rented for the first time summer of 2009

Page Views This month: 0 This year: 0 Since listed: 2,767