1 / 17



Pets allowed:
Wi-Fi available:

Description from owner

A spectacular pastoral setting, this historic compound features a country manor home and custom built guest house on 8 acres. The main residence has been beautifully restored with architectural details intact but with all the most up-to-date amenities. This gracious home has a relaxed country décor with a large living room with wood-burning fireplace and is flanked by a delightful sunroom overlooking a meadow. The library is flanked by another screened sunroom overlooking the lawn and garden. The formal dining room with French doors leads to a private stone terrace which is another outdoor dining space, perfect for breakfast, lunch and dinner. The generous eat-in kitchen is outfitted with top of-the-line appliances (Sub-Zero and Viking stove) and two dishwashers. If you’d rather rest and relax and have someone else command the kitchen, might we recommend a visit from Kyle’s Catering. There are 3 bedrooms and 3.5 baths, including an en suite Master with attached private office. Each exquisite marble bath features a beautiful antique commode.

The Carriage house is flooded with light and casual chic decor. There are 3 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, and open living and dining space with French doors leading to a terrace overlooking the heated pool and views of the vast land reserve beyond. Ultra-private and serene, the park-like grounds are filled with native trees, plantings and flowering plants. Simply divine.

This property is offered with a choice of the Main House alone or the Main House + Carriage House. The house is available on a year-round basis or for the summer period; the minimum rental period is one month.

Main House only:

MD-LD: $115K

June: $35K

July: $45K

August: $50K,

July 1 to LD: $90K

Main House and carriage house:

MD-LD: $150K

June: $40K


August: $55K

July 1 to LD: $110K

Beds: 2 Queen Beds, 10 Twin Beds

About the area

Shelter Island Historical Compound is located in Shelter Island, New York. We are two hours away from New York City and offer everything you will need to recharge. Outside of our home, you will find Shelter Island to be a quaint and calm town that offers wonderful dining, beautiful natural trails, access to water, biking and dozens of other relaxing activities to help you recharge and refresh.

Owner profile

Christine H



  • Air conditioning
  • Grill
  • Heating
  • Fireplace
  • High Speed Internet
  • Linen provided
  • Private outdoor pool (unheated)
  • Parking Included


  • Clothes dryer
  • Dishwasher
  • DVD player
  • Fax machine
  • Hair dryer
  • Iron
  • CD player
  • Refrigerator
  • Satellite TV
  • Microwave
  • Stove
  • Telephone
  • Toaster
  • TV
  • Washing machine


  • Bikes
  • Cycling Trips
  • Fishing
  • Water sports
  • Horse riding


Help other travelers decide where to stay

This holiday home hasn’t got any reviews yet. The average rating on Vacation Home Rentals is four out of five. This place could be newly added or perhaps it’s a well kept secret. Either way, it’s time to reveal all.

Be the first to write a review